1st Ave. Pizza, "Your Hometown Pizzeria," located in the heart of downtown Atlantic Highlands, N.J., is a mom and pop establishment with a friendly family run staff serving the areas only award-winning pizza. We offer pizza by-the-slice, salads, hot and cold subs, delightful desserts and a variety of homemade gourmet pies, including our signature "Grandma" pie.
We understand the reality of busy schedules. For your convenience, we offer take-out and delivery to your home,
office or any location within a 5 mile radius of Atlantic Highlands.
1st Ave. Pizza takes great pride in supporting local causes.
We show our support through pizza donations, fundraising nights or just volunteering our time to support causes we
Check Out What N.J. 101.5 F.M. says about our Pizza!
2013 Readers Choice Winner
Monmouth Health & Life Magazine
"Top 10 Best Slice in Jersey”
N.J. 101.5, Ray “Jersey Guy” Rossi
"One of the Best Pizzas in Monmouth County"
Asbury Park Press
Readers Choice Awards
Voted as one of the "Top 5 Best Pizzas in New Jersey"
Named as one of the "60 Shore Things to Do" on the
Edge Travel Magazine
"5 Stars! If there’s a haven for pizza lovers, it should be
Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday
2 Large Plain Pizza's
19.99 plus tax